%20-%20BF%2004_09_2025.png)
No Accountant Knows Everything: A Real Look at Imposter Syndrome in Accounting
- Brett J. Federer, CPA
- Nov 13
- 6 min read
In accounting, there’s this idea that you’re supposed to know everything all the time. Every rule, every exception, every treatment. And if you don’t have an answer immediately, it can feel like you’re already doing something wrong. But the longer I’ve been in this field, the more I’ve realized that’s not how accounting works. The profession is far too big for any one person to know all of it, and pretending otherwise only creates more pressure.
Imposter syndrome doesn’t come from being unqualified. It comes from working in a field where accuracy matters and the rules change constantly. You’re expected to be steady even when the work itself is full of nuance and judgment. That kind of pressure sits with you, and it makes you second-guess what you “should” know versus what’s actually realistic.
The Reality Behind Imposter Syndrome
For me, imposter syndrome usually shows up when I question whether I know enough. Not because I doubt my ability, but because accounting puts you in situations where you feel like you’re supposed to answer instantly. Even when the question is something that hasn’t come up in years, or something most people would reasonably need time to review, there’s still that internal voice saying, “You should know this already.”
There’s also a fear that comes from forgetting something you used to know. Accounting is huge. Entire areas go untouched for years depending on the companies you work with. When those topics suddenly show up again, it’s easy to think, “Why didn’t I remember this?” even though the truth is that anyone would need to refresh themselves after so much time has passed.
That’s the real core of imposter syndrome in this field. It’s the conflict between what the profession expects on the surface and how the work actually functions underneath. Your mind wants to feel safe by knowing everything upfront, but accounting requires you to slow down, look things up, or confirm assumptions — and doing that can feel wrong even when it’s exactly what the role demands.
Why No Accountant Truly Knows Everything
The deeper you go into accounting, the clearer it becomes that no one has every answer. There are simply too many branches. Financial reporting, cost accounting, inventory, cash flow, systems, technical memos, payroll, month-end structure, and an entire universe of tax rules that change constantly. Each area could be a full career, and some people spend decades specializing in just one.
Experience shapes what you understand. Someone from SaaS (Software as a Service) sees issues differently than someone from manufacturing, hospitality, or retail. Nobody sees the entire picture because nobody has been exposed to everything. That’s not a lack of skill — it’s the nature of the profession.
Once you accept that, the expectation of “knowing everything” starts to soften.
The Tax Example That Proves the Point
One area that illustrates this better than anything is tax. I do not handle tax work, but I’ve always respected the professionals who do because their world changes more than any other part of the profession. The laws are rewritten, updated, or clarified constantly. Some rules override others. Certain provisions contradict the plain reading of the code. Many sections reference other sections that reference more sections. And the treatment can differ entirely depending on entity type, structure, state, elections, ownership changes, or the character of the income. And every time you follow a rule, it splits. One branch becomes two, and each of those becomes two more.
With that many moving parts, it is completely normal for two highly qualified tax professionals to approach the same complex situation differently. Not because either is wrong, but because the code allows multiple valid paths depending on judgment.
For me, this is the clearest reminder that no accountant can know everything. The profession is simply too broad, and the deeper you go into any specialty, the more variations you uncover. What matters is not perfect recall but recognizing when something needs more review. Good accountants know when to slow down, when research is necessary, and when a detail might change the outcome. Judgment ends up being the real skill — and founders benefit from that far more than they benefit from instant answers.
What Founders Should Actually Expect
Founders sometimes expect fast answers because they think of accounting as a clean set of rules. But in practice, most situations require a moment to think. Even straightforward questions can have ripple effects depending on timing, treatment, or how something interacts with the rest of the close process.
Good accounting isn’t built on speed. It’s built on clarity. Sometimes clarity comes quickly because you’ve seen the situation before. Sometimes it doesn’t, and the right move is to pause and make sure the answer lines up with the business. That pause protects both sides far more than a fast response ever could.
My Own Journey With This
During this past year, as I’ve worked to open my own firm and go out on my own, I’ve noticed I’ve been riddled with imposter syndrome. It shows up more now than it ever did in my past. When you’re part of a department, you always have people around you, and that naturally gives you a buffer. But when you’re working alone and every decision lands on you, it honestly feels scary. There’s this constant pressure to make the right call because there isn’t anyone to double-check something with.
I also feel it when I think about talking to potential clients. There’s this expectation I put on myself to know every answer on the spot, even though accounting has never worked that way. Some questions need time. Some things need research. But the moment I imagine someone asking something challenging, my mind jumps straight to, “You’re supposed to know this immediately,” even when that isn’t true or realistic.
The sales and marketing side has been its own challenge. It’s all new for me, and anything new makes me second-guess myself until I’ve done it enough times to feel comfortable. This whole year has been like that. I’ve had to push through a lot of uncertainty, and every step forward has come with a little bit of hesitation.
The imposter feelings don’t come from not being capable. They come from being smart enough to know I don’t know everything and from wanting to build this firm the right way. Over time, it gets a little less intimidating, but it’s still something I work through every day.
Aptitude and Attitude Matter More Than Certainty
I’ve learned that the people who think they know everything usually don’t. Accounting is too big for that kind of confidence, and trying to act like you’ve mastered all of it ends up getting in the way. The best accountants I’ve worked with are the ones who know they don’t know everything. They never pretend otherwise. They stay curious, they stay open, and they stay willing to learn.
That attitude matters more than anything. When you approach the work like a student instead of someone who has it all figured out, you naturally slow down when something feels off. You double-check details. You ask questions. You look into things even when you’re pretty sure you’re right. That mindset protects the quality of the work far more than perfect recall ever could.
Aptitude plays a role too. Some people can connect dots quickly, see patterns, and spot issues before they grow. But it only works when the attitude is there — when you’re not afraid to pause and rethink something. That combination of curiosity and steady thinking ends up being far more valuable than someone who answers fast just to sound confident.
Founders get better outcomes from someone who is still learning than someone who claims they’ve learned it all.
Why This Matters in Controller-Level Work
Controller-level work isn’t about being a walking encyclopedia. It’s about keeping the financials stable month after month. It’s about making sure things connect properly, spotting issues early, and fixing misalignment before it becomes a problem. None of that requires knowing everything upfront. It requires paying attention and being consistent.
In this role, saying “I don’t know yet” is often the smarter move. It means you’re treating the numbers seriously. It means you’re not making decisions just to appear certain. The goal is accuracy, not speed. The right answer is the one that holds up, and that sometimes means taking a second look.
No accountant knows everything, and expecting that from anyone isn’t realistic. The field is too big and changes too often for full certainty. Imposter syndrome shows up because the expectations are high and the work matters. But the truth is, what makes someone good at this isn’t knowing it all — it’s staying calm, thinking clearly, and slowing down when the situation needs it. That’s where the real value is, and that’s what founders actually depend on.
If your bookkeeping is handled but your financials still feel uncertain, it may be time for a structured month-end process. My Financial Clarity Package provides a consistent close, clean reporting, and stable numbers founders can rely on.
Build Structure That Frees You.
AI where it works. Humans where it counts.
